New to Sly Flourish? Start Here or subscribe to the newsletter.
by Mike on 31 July 2017
This article updates the original published on 31 August 2017.
It's important for GMs to spend time and attention on the treasure and magic items awarded to characters. Selecting treasure is one of the eight steps from Return of the Lazy Dungeon Master with good reason. Treasure and magic items matter a lot to characters and players and yet their dispersement lies completely in the hands of the GM.
Use a mixture of random treasure and hand-selected magic items based on what fits the characters and what players want based on their wish-lists. Roll random treasure parcels and customize them based on what offers the most fun to the group. It's quick, easy, and offers a high value for our game.
Many GMs ask how much loot to distribute and how often.
A couple of RPG community members did great work breaking down how much treasure one can expect across a campaign. DM David did so in his article "What is the typical amount of treasure awarded in a fifth-edition Dungeons & Dragons campaign?". So did Paul Hughes and Andy Pearlman. If you want to dive deep into the math, these articles have you covered.
Like many aspects of D&D, I argue it's better to hang on with a loose grip and not worry too much about it.
The breakdowns linked above, and books like the 2014 Dungeon Master's Guide, and Level Up Advanced 5e's Trials and Treasure book recommend offering up one to three hoards per character level. That feels about right to me too.
Don't sweat it too much, though. Drop in hoards when they feel right and when the opportunity arises in the story of the game.
Chapter 7 of the 2014 Dungeon Master's Guide has fine tables for rolling treasure hoards. Choose the challenge rating of the biggest monster defeated or pick a CR based on the overall danger of the quest (or even just an equivalent CR to the level of the characters if you have nothing else to base it on) and roll on the appropriate tables.
The equivalent random treasure tables in the Trials and Treasure book for Level Up Advanced 5e are probably better but adding all the CRs of the defeated monsters isn't as straight forward as focusing on the highest CR monster. You can half the CR values in A5e's tables and use them the same way as the DMG tables and things work fine.
Online random treasure tools often work better than rolling lots of dice. It's really fast to roll a treasure hoard using tools like Donjon's Treasure Generator, the Level Up Advanced 5e Random Treasure Generator, or the Lazy GM's Random Generator (a reward for Sly Flourish Patrons). Because it's so fast, you can roll a bunch of hoards and pick the one that best fits the situation in the game and the fun of your group. Which random magic items look cool for the current situation? Does the hoard have too many or too few consumable magic items? Keep rolling until you like what you see.
We're not beholden to the results of such random treasure hoards. We can always roll on individual magic item tables to drop things in but even better is picking items directly for our characters.
Ask your players for the kinds of magic items they're interested in for their character. Write this wish list down in your notes and review it when reviewing the characters for your next game (step 1 of the eight steps from Return). Then, if the time feels right, drop in an item for one of the characters, ensuring you're keeping track of who got what so no one's left out.
The "Special Features" tables on page 142 and 143 of chapter 7 in the 2014 Dungeon Master's Guide offer fantastic ways to customize magic items based on the item's creators or intended users, history, minor properties, and quirks. These tables directly inspired my "condition", "description", and "origin" tables on page 6 of the Lazy DM's Companion and the "origin", "condition", and "spell effects" tables on page 13 and 14 of the Lazy DM's Workbook.
You can also build your own faction or origin table to flavor magic items based on the campaign world you're running – either homebrew or published. Here's an example of some factions of Midgard:
When you're playing in a campaign world, build your own faction list like this to flavor your own monuments, one-use magic items, weapons, and armor.
Tie your custom magic items to the secrets and clues so your players can discover more of the world around them while enjoying their new fine loot.
Sly Flourish Patrons get access to the Lazy GM's Random Generator. This is a generator for monuments, one-use magic items, treasure, quests, NPCs, and more. Each component can be flavored with over ten different campaign worlds and include spells from the 2014 Player's Handbook, Level Up Advanced 5e, and Kobold Press's Deep Magic books. It's a great tool to help you build fantastic situations for your games. Join the Patreon and get access right now.
Share this article with your friends using this link: https://slyflourish.com/awarding_magic_items.html
Have a question or want to contact me? Check out Sly Flourish's Frequently Asked Questions.
This site uses affiliate links to Amazon and DriveThruRPG. Thanks for your support!